Local Insurance Agents That Are Here For You
At Pueblo Insurance, we pride ourselves on being your friendly, local, and independent insurance agency, dedicated to finding the right policies for your needs. Our inviting approach ensures that you feel right at home as we help you through the process.
Our team in Pueblo, CO, works closely with major carriers to provide you with the best coverage options that fit your unique lifestyle and budget. With our commitment to personalized service and expert advice, we make protecting what matters most to you a hassle-free, enjoyable experience. Let us help you uncover your options in the vast world of insurance with confidence, dedication, and care!
About Our Business
Pueblo Insurance was founded in 2009 by a father and daughter-in-law team, Bill Graham and Deborah Marino, who brought a wealth of experience to the agency with a combined 35 years in the insurance industry at the time. Bill had formerly worked for a “Captive” carrier and Deborah had been employed with an independent agency in Denver, providing them both with a foundation of knowledge to serve the Pueblo community by starting their own independent agency.
While Bill has since retired, his vision and commitment to the community continue to inspire us. Deborah, with nearly 30 years of individual expertise, now leads Pueblo Insurance in offering personalized solutions for every customer. Our agency has grown significantly over the years, now including an in-office customer service representative, Nikki, who shares the same passion for outstanding service.
Part of the SIAA
Community Involvement
As a way to give back to the community that has entrusted us with their insurance needs, we are proud to have sponsored and supported various local schools and community activities in the past, including:
- Centennial High School Musical and Marching Band
- CSU-Pueblo Automotive Department
- Diversified Industries
- Junior League of Pueblo
- Pueblo County Scholarship Pageant
- Pueblo Courthouse Holiday Lighting Ceremony
- Pueblo Knight Basketball Team
Our Staff
Deborah Marino
Owner and Co-founder
Learn More
Ashley “Nikki” Frost
Licensed Insurance Agent
Learn More
Nikki is a licensed insurance agent. Her background is in communications and customer service, with an associate’s degree in mass communications. Nikki continues to add to her knowledge of all things insurance and is beyond excited to help you. She spends her personal time with her husband and three children. Nikki’s children have kept her busy, attending dance recitals at Memorial Hall, Volleyball games at the Pueblo YMCA, Baseball at Runyon field and even band, and concert recitals for both their elementary and middle schools. She still enjoys simple pleasures like her visits to the local library, and playing any sport or game, her siblings, nieces and nephews can rope her into. Being a Pueblo native, Nikki is invested in improving the people in this community’s insurance experience, though striving to maintain the agency’s focus on customer service.
Serving All of Colorado, Including:
Canon City
Colorado City
Colorado Springs
Florence
Fountain
Penrose
Pueblo
Pueblo West
Rye
Southern Colorado
Frequently Asked Questions
Why should I choose Pueblo Insurance instead of buying insurance online?
We work with multiple highly rated insurance companies to compare coverage and pricing for you. Our team takes the time to understand your needs and recommend options that fit your lifestyle and budget.
What types of insurance do you offer?
We provide auto, home, renters, condo, motorcycle, RV, boat, umbrella, and other personal insurance solutions through a wide network of trusted carriers.
Insurance rates seem to keep increasing. Can you help?
Yes. While insurance rates are influenced by many market factors, we regularly compare options across multiple carriers to help identify competitive pricing and appropriate coverage.
I'm not sure what coverage I actually need. Can you explain it?
Absolutely. We’ll walk through your options in plain language so you understand your coverage, deductibles, and available protections before making a decision.
What happens if I have questions after purchasing a policy?
Our team is here to provide ongoing support—not just at the time of purchase. We’re happy to answer questions, assist with policy changes, and help you navigate your insurance needs.
Will someone help me review my coverage over time?
Absolutely. As your needs change, we’ll review your policies and help ensure your coverage continues to fit your life and goals.
How does an independent insurance agency benefit me?
Because we’re independent, we can compare policies from multiple insurance companies instead of being limited to one provider, helping you find coverage that best fits your needs.
Do you only serve Pueblo?
No. We proudly serve customers throughout Pueblo, many communities across Southern Colorado, as well as all of Colorado.
Can you help if my insurance needs change?
Yes. Whether you’re buying a new home, adding a vehicle, starting a business, or experiencing another life change, we’ll review your policies and recommend updates as needed.
Can you help me compare my current insurance with other options?
Yes. We can review your existing policies, compare them with options from multiple carriers, and explain any differences so you can make an informed decision.
Call 719-542-0948 or email puebloinsurance@comcast.net to contact us today.